I LOVE films. In fact, I have a film degree. Films entertain us. That’s a simplistic description but it’s accurate. They entertain us, they can make us think about the human experience in ways we hadn’t before, and they can share with us a piece of history. Sometimes they do all three. Books and plays have the ability to do the same but there’s something about films that really is magical. There are a few films that allow me to fully realize how much I love films. In my mind these films hold the coveted title of masterpiece. There are other films that are masterpieces too but they do not inspire me in the ways these films on this list do.
Here are the top 10 in chronological order.
Oh, and here be *SPOILERS* I’m going to write with the assumption that you’ve either seen the movie or aren’t going to bother to watch it. If you don’t want to read spoilers because you want to see the film and you want the plot to be a surprise, then skip the paragraph.
1. The Story of Vernon and Irene Castle (1939)
Director- H.C. Potter
Starring- Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers
At the turn of the 20th century, the world was taken by storm with the husband/wife dancing team of Vernon and Irene Castle. Not only were they happily married, they were trend setters (Irene cut off her hair and made it okay for women to have short hair. My current hair style thanks her), and exceedingly talented. It was only fitting that when Irene was ready to have her love story put on the silver screen the most popular and talented dancing film duo would play the parts. Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers proved they could dance, sing, and romance each other. With this film they proved they could act. I had no idea who Vernon and Irene were when I first watched this film. I had no idea that Vernon died during WWI. The last scene with Irene looking out a window and seeing her and Vernon dance made me sob. It’s just sad. It also made me realize the power of a true love story being truly told. In a world of romantic movies, it was refreshing to see a film that showed a couple who knew and loved each other for better or worse. Irene always carried Vernon in her heart. I will always carry this film in mine.
2. The Shop Around the Corner
(1940)
Director- Ernest Lubitsch
Starring- Margaret Sullivan and James Stewart
I can count on two fingers the number of strictly romantic movies I like. I think Hollywood has a hard time showing the complexity of finding a person to spend the rest of your life with. At the end of almost all romantic films, the protagonists declare true love to each other after only knowing each other for a day. The Shop Around the Corner is the only one of the two that I count as a masterpiece. In fact I wrote an entire college essay about this film. (I got an A) Maybe because the romance blossoms between two retail employees and that’s how my own personal love story started or maybe it’s because it’s such a perfectly sweet film. I don’t know precisely why this film speaks to me but it’s well worth the watch. I love the moment James Stewart’s Alfred discovers Margaret Sullivan’s Kiara is his pen pal. They are enemies at the store where they work but they fall in love over anonymous letters they write to each other. It takes Kiara a bit longer to learn of her pen pal’s identity but when she does, my heart soars. It makes me love love stories. Almost. In case you’re full of curiosity, the only other romantic film I love is Notting Hill (1999). Oh, and I consider The Princess Bride (1987) to be beyond a category.
3. Auntie Mame
(1958)
Director- Morton DaCosta
Starring- Rosalind Russell
This is my all time favorite film. Auntie Mame has yet to cease to be hilarious. Sure, it’s basically line for line the stage play and the sets don’t really go beyond what you would find on Broadway but the colors and the comedy and Rosalind Russell. I love her in every movie she acted in but she makes this movie. She’s larger than life. Deep down, underneath my meek exterior, I’m your Auntie Mame.
4. Cannibal! The Musical
(1993)
Director- Trey Parker
Staring- Trey Parker and Matt Stone
“Hello, I’m Alfred Packer and this is my horse Liane.” Before there was South Park there is my other all time favorite film. I can quote this movie on cue. I’ve listened to the director’s drunken commentary on more than three occasions. Trey Parker somehow makes the tragedy that was Alfred Packer’s story hilarious. Alfred Packer is the only person in US history to have been convicted of cannibalism. His story mirrors the Donner Party story, except he was the only one to survive in his group. I’ve been to the massacre site and to see how freaking close they where to their destination is frustrating. While I was trying to be respectful at the burial site, two women got out of their car giggling. Then I started laughing and we sang ‘Let’s Build a Snowman.’ How can you not laugh?
There is one bit of Trey Parker history that one needs to know before viewing the film. Trey Parker had a fiancé named Liane. They were all set to get married when he caught her cheating on him. I’ll leave it at that. Enjoy.
5. Walking Across Egypt
(1999)
Director- Arthur Allen Seildelman
Starring- Ellen Burstyn and Jonathan Taylor Thomas
Burstyn plays a widow with two ungrateful children. She’s waiting around to die. Thomas plays a delinquent teen in juvie with no clear path to a bright future. They meet and together they forge a friendship and the unloved Westley (Thomas) gets adopted by Mattie (Burstyn). He gives her a reason to live and she gives him a chance. It’s as simple as that. It’s a simple film that was released straight to DVD for Blockbuster (May the company rest in piece) and it always renews my faith in humanity. Every single viewing. The movie has never let me down.
6. Unbreakable
(2000)
Director- M. Night Shyamalan
Starring- Bruce Willis and Samuel L. Jackson
This is the only movie where I walked out of the theater jumping up and down for joy. I love comic books. Especially when I was a teenager. I was 21 when ‘Unbreakable’ came out but I was young enough to remember in shining detail my teenage years. To this day I still love comic book movies but ‘Unbreakable’ was the first comic book movie for comic book lovers. M. Night Shyamalan had recently garnered a lot of fame because of his twist ending in ‘The Sixth Sense’ and early reviews mentioned ‘Unbreakable’ also had a twist ending. I figured out Sense’s ending long before the major reveal and I was confident I was right about ‘Unbreakable.’ I needed Samuel L. Jackson’s Elijah Price to be the evil mastermind to the hero, David Dunn (Bruce Willis) Then Elijah said those magic words: “You know why, David? It’s because of the kids. They called me Mr. Glass.” I clapped really loud and laughed, making the people around me jump. It was the perfect ending to a perfect movie.
7. There Will Be Blood
(2007)
Director- Paul Thomas Anderson
Starring- Daniel Day-Lewis and Paul Dano
When I first saw this film in the theater, I hated it. In fact, I thought it to be quite possibly the worst movie I had ever seen. I had a strong and emotional negative reaction to it. Then the movie started eating away at my thoughts. It filled my dreams. It was all I could think about. It wore me down, so naturally I went to see it again in the theater and fell in love. It’s such a dark twisted tale of pure evilness in human form. It pained me when it didn’t win Best Picture at the Academy Awards that year. What movie could have been better than the film that ended with the talk of drinking milkshakes? The Academy apparently believed ‘No Country for Old Men’ was better. I disagree.
8. Milk
(2008)
Director- Gus Van Sant
Starring- Sean Penn and Josh Brolin
The editing. The editing. The editing. This is simply the best edited film ever to have existed. The acting wasn’t bad either. I want to leave it at that but I fear that may be a disservice to Harvey Milk. It’s just that the editing breaths life into the story of the first openly gay person elected to office. The editing gives a punch to a story that is already pounding on the doors of US history not to be forgotten. The editing honors the old saying that history is not the dead past of the living but the living past of the dead.
9. The Secret Life of Walter Mitty
(2013)
Director- Ben Stiller
Starring- Ben Stiller and Kristin Wiig
The original short story by James Thurber was a fun little read about nothing really. The version Danny Kaye stars in (1947) gives the story a plot and an antagonist. Ben Stiller throws the story off a cliff and allows it to soar. It’s not quite a feel good film but it about finding happiness in a world of chaos. Even when that chaos is in your head. I was grinning the entire way through this movie when I saw it in the theater. I can’t help but look at my DVD copy and smile. It just makes me happy knowing this film exists.
10. Bohemian Rhapsody
(2018)
I’m a sucker for stories about an influential person that ends in sadness. I can’t help it. Life is full of tragedy. I don’t have time to see many movies in the theater these days, so it’s a big deal when I take time out of my full schedule to go to the theater. I’ve seen this film twice. It may not be perfectly truthful in its telling of the story of Freddie Mercury and Queen but it’s a love letter to their music. It’s a love letter to Freddie Mercury. It honors him by showing how awesome he was, loneliness and all. As of right now, the Academy has yet to give out their highest honor and I hope with all my heart that will it goes to ‘Bohemian Rhapsody.’
UPDATE: Curse you Academy!